Screw Down Metal Roof vs Shingles

Screw Down Metal Roof vs Shingles

Replacing a roof is a big job and a big expense. Before you decide which type of roof to install, it’s important to understand the pros and cons of both options: asphalt shingle roofs and screw-down metal roofs.

When comparing asphalt shingles to screw-down metal roofs, metal roofs offer more resistance to wind, sun, and tree damage than asphalt roofs. In addition, metal roof repair is easier than with standing seam metal roofs. However, metal roofs may require fastener replacement every 10-15 years.

Both types of roof have their advantages and disadvantages; it’s important to weigh these pros and cons carefully before making your decision. Read on for more information about asphalt shingle roofing and screw-down metal roofing.

Comparing Asphalt Shingle Roofs and Screw-down Metal Roofs

Knowing the benefits and drawbacks of each type can help you decide which one is right for your home.

Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Screw Down Metal Roof vs Shingles 1

Asphalt shingle roofs are one of the most commonly installed roofing materials in residential homes. They typically have a predictable life expectancy and are readily available at many home improvement stores or from local contractors.

However, there are some drawbacks to using asphalt shingles on your roof. The ballast or granules, asphalt and fiberglass used can often shed over time, making them vulnerable to wind damage, tree damage or installation errors.

Screw-down Metal Roofs

Screw-down metal roofs offer several advantages when compared to asphalt shingle roofs. For starters, they can sometimes be price competitive with asphalt roofs depending on size and scope of the project.

In addition, they are easier to repair than standing seam metal roofs, can last longer when correctly installed and maintained, and offer more resistance to wind damage, sun exposure and tree damage than asphalt roofs do.

However, if incorrectly installed these types of steel roofing systems have a shorter life expectancy than other materials and may require fasteners to be replaced every 10-15 years as they can corrode over time.

Screw Down Metal Roof or Shingles: What to Choose in Different Situations

Depending on the circumstances of your particular case scenario, one type of roof may be better suited than the other.

Cost Considerations

Asphalt shingle roofs are generally less expensive than screw-down metal roofs. However, depending on the size and complexity of the job at hand, prices can vary significantly. In some cases, a screw-down metal roof can be just as affordable as an asphalt shingle roof (or even more so). It is important to get multiple quotes from different contractors for both types of roofs before making a decision.

Longevity & Weather Resistance

Metal roofs are known for their durability and long lifespan. When correctly installed and maintained, a screw-down metal roof can last up to 50 years or more with little need for repair or replacement. Asphalt shingles have a much shorter lifespan – typically around 20 years – but do offer some protection against wind damage. Additionally, metal roofs are better equipped to stand up to strong winds and other extreme weather conditions due to their solid construction.

Installation Ease & Noise Level

Installation of an asphalt shingle roof is generally quicker and easier than that of a screw-down metal roof. However, it is important to note that aluminum nails should be used when installing asphalt shingles since regular nails may corrode over time due to exposure to moisture. Metal roofs can also be noisier when it rains due to the solid construction; this could be a consideration if you live in an area with frequent rainfall or you plan on using your attic space for living quarters.


In conclusion, what type of roof you choose will ultimately depend upon the specific situation at hand. Both screw-down metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofs have advantages and drawbacks β€” it’s important to weigh all factors carefully before making a decision.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of implementing screw-down metal roofing over shingles?

Advantages of Implementing Screw-Down Metal Roofing over Shingles

If you’re considering replacing your old shingle roof with a metal one, you’ll need to weigh the pros and cons to decide which option is best for you. Here are some of the advantages of implementing screw-down metal roofing over shingles:

1. Durability

Metal roofing is well-known for its durability and longevity. It can withstand strong winds, heavy rain, and even hailstorms without sustaining any significant damage. This means that you’ll spend less money on repairs and replacement costs in the long-term if you choose to go with metal roofing.

2. Energy Efficiency

Metal roofing can also help reduce your energy bills by keeping your home cooler during hot summer months. Metal reflects the sun’s rays instead of absorbing them, which means your home won’t get as hot as it would with shingles. This is a significant advantage for homeowners living in areas with hot climates.

3. Low Maintenance

Metal roofing requires very little maintenance; it doesn’t absorb moisture or mildew, and it’s resistant to rotting and insect damage. This means you won’t have to spend much time or money cleaning or repairing your roof over time.

Disadvantages of Implementing Screw-Down Metal Roofing over Shingles

While there are plenty of advantages of switching to metal roofing, it’s also essential to consider the potential disadvantages before making a final decision. Here are some downsides to implementing screw-down metal roofing over shingles:

1. Cost

One of the primary disadvantages of metal roofing is cost – it can be considerably more expensive to purchase and install than shingles. Depending on the type of metal you choose, installation can cost up to twice as much as shingles.

2. Noise

Metal roofing can be noisy when it rains or hails; the sound can be particularly loud if the roofing is not installed with proper insulation. This can be particularly disruptive if you live in a house with an open floor plan or want a quiet home environment.

3. Aesthetics

Some homeowners might not appreciate the look of metal roofing; it may clash with the style of their house or neighborhood. While modern metal roofing options come in various colors and styles, they may not suit everyone’s taste or preferences.

4. Installation Time

Metal roofing takes longer to install than shingles, which can be a significant drawback for homeowners who want to complete the project quickly. The additional installation time can also add to the cost of the project.\

Do Screw Down Metal Roofs Leak?

Screw down metal roofs often suffer from leaks due to damaged or worn-out screws and fasteners. When the screws back out, it creates an entry point for water to seep into the building, causing water damage and potential safety concerns. One solution is to remove these damaged components and replace them with new ones.

It is important to regularly inspect the fasteners and screws of a metal roof to avoid leaks.

Over time, screws may become rusted or corroded, making them susceptible to breaking off or backing out. By identifying and replacing these components early on, building owners can avoid costly water damage and maintain a safe and structurally sound building.

How Long Do Screw Down Metal Roofs Last?

Screw down metal roofs can last up to 20 years if installed properly and with no maintenance required. However, maintenance can increase its lifespan to up to 30 years. One thing to keep in mind when using screw down metal roofs is that these systems are screwed tightly, which prevents the roof from expanding and contracting naturally.

This might lead to premature wear and tear, so it’s essential to conduct regular maintenance to ensure that everything is in good condition.

Overall, screw down metal roofs are an excellent choice for those looking for durability and longevity. They’re affordable, easy to install and provide excellent protection against the elements.

Plus, with proper maintenance, you can ensure you get the most out of your screw down metal roof. So, if you’re planning to install a metal roof, screw down metal roofs might be the perfect option for you.

Is It Cheaper to Install Metal Roof or Shingles?

While metal roofing has its own unique advantages, affordability isn’t one of them. Installing a metal roof is generally more expensive than installing shingles, as metal panels themselves cost more and require more labor to install. In fact, you might end up paying two or three times the cost of an asphalt shingle roof to have a metal roof installed.

That being said, you should consider the long-term benefits of a metal roof, as they are typically more durable and energy-efficient than shingle roofs. Ultimately, the choice between metal roofing and shingles depends on your budget, preferences, and priorities.

What Are the Disadvantages of Metal Roofing?

Metal roofing might be an excellent choice given its durability and lifespan, but this type of roofing also has its disadvantages. For one, it is relatively expensive, and installation can be a bit more complicated compared to other types of roofing. It requires skills, experience, and specialized tools, which not all roofing contractors possess.

Thus, finding a reliable installer can be a challenge, and mistakes during installation can lead to leaks and damages that can be costly to fix.

Another disadvantage of metal roofing is that it can be noisy. In areas with heavy rainfall or hailstorms, metal roofing can produce noise that can be loud and disruptive. While some people might find it soothing, others might find it annoying, especially if they work from home or have small children trying to sleep.

Additionally, metal roofing can be prone to denting, which can compromise its structural integrity and reduce its durability. Dents can be caused by hail, falling branches, or even foot traffic, which can be a concern for homeowners who value the aesthetic appeal of their roofing.

What Are the Two Biggest Concerns to a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs can be a great investment for any homeowner. They are durable, energy-efficient, and eco-friendly. However, they also come with their own set of concerns.

The two biggest concerns to a metal roof are improper installation and the potential for corrosion.

Improper installation can result in leaks and other issues that can compromise the integrity of the roof. This is one of the biggest concerns to a metal roof. However, if you find a skilled and experienced contractor who can install it correctly, you should have no problem.

Another significant concern is corrosion. Metal roofs can be vulnerable to rust and other forms of corrosion, especially when exposed to the elements. Regular maintenance can help prevent this from happening and prolong the life of your metal roof.

Do Metal Roofs Leak More Than Shingles?

According to studies, metal roofs do not leak more than shingles. In fact, metal roofing offers better protection against leaks and water damage compared to traditional shingles. This is because metal roofing systems are designed to interlock and fasten tightly, creating a seamless and waterproof barrier against the elements.

On the other hand, shingles can start to loosen and warp over time, which can compromise their ability to keep water out. Additionally, shingles are vulnerable to wind and hail damage, which can lead to leaks and costly repairs. Overall, metal roofing is a more reliable and durable option for homeowners who want to ensure that their roof won’t leak or cause damage to their property.

Which Is Better a Metal Roof or Shingles?

Well, it really depends on your personal wants and needs. A metal roof might be more durable and can last much longer, but it can also be more expensive. On the other hand, shingles can be less expensive but may not last as long.

It’s important to consider your budget, the climate you live in, and the overall look you want for your home. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, you just have to weigh them to figure out which is better for you.

What Are Drawbacks to Having a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs are becoming increasingly popular among homeowners due to their durability and longevity. Although metal roofs have their advantages, they also have some drawbacks to consider. Firstly, metal roofs can be noisy during heavy rain or hail, which can be disturbing for some people.

Secondly, metal roofs can be expensive to install compared to other roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles. Additionally, metal roofs can dent easily, which can be unsightly and affect the aesthetic appearance of the roof. Lastly, metal roofs can get hot during the summer months, which can increase cooling costs for the home.

Overall, while metal roofs have their benefits, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

What Are the Negatives of a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs may have some disadvantages that homeowners should be aware of. First, they tend to be more expensive than traditional asphalt shingle roofs. Additionally, metal roofs can be noisy during heavy rain or hailstorms.

However, proper insulation can help reduce the noise level inside the house.

Another potential negative of metal roofs is their susceptibility to denting from hail or falling debris. While some modern metal roofing materials are designed to be more durable and resistant to dents, it’s still important to carefully consider the environment in which the roof will be installed. Finally, some people may find the appearance of a metal roof less aesthetically pleasing than traditional roofing materials.

Ultimately, the decision to install a metal roof should be based on a careful consideration of these potential negatives in addition to the many benefits that metal roofs can offer.

What Are the Two Biggest Concerns to a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs are highly durable and long lasting, but they still have some concerns that need to be addressed. The two biggest concerns for a metal roof are rust and improper installation. Rust can occur due to exposure to moisture and air, causing damage and corrosion to the roof.

Proper installation is also important, as an improperly installed metal roof can result in leaks and other issues over time.

To avoid rust, it’s important to choose a high-quality metal roofing material that is resistant to corrosion. You can also minimize the risk of rust by ensuring that your roof is properly sealed and maintained over time. As for installation, it’s crucial to work with a professional roofing contractor who has experience with metal roofs.

They can ensure that your roof is installed correctly and meets all of the necessary structural requirements. By addressing these concerns, you can enjoy the many benefits of a metal roof, including increased home value and energy efficiency, for years to come.

Do Metal Roofs Leak More Than Shingles?

Metal roofs are often seen as a more durable and long-lasting option than shingles. However, one common misconception is that metal roofs are more prone to leaking. This assumption is not necessarily true.

In fact, metal roofs can be just as leak-resistant as shingle roofs, if not more so.

The key to preventing leaks in metal roofs is proper installation and maintenance. When installed correctly, with quality materials and by a skilled professional, metal roofs can last for decades without any leaks. Additionally, regular inspections and maintenance can help catch any issues before they become major problems.

So, the bottom line is that metal roofs are not inherently more leaky than shingles. It all comes down to proper installation and upkeep.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a Metal Roof Devalue a House?

Believing that a metal roof devalues a house is just a misconception. In fact, it is quite the opposite. Metal roofs provide several benefits that can increase a house’s value.

They last longer than other roof types, require minimal maintenance, and add an attractive feature to the house. So, having a metal roof is actually a good thing because it can make a house more appealing to potential buyers and increase its overall value.

Moreover, metal roofing is becoming more popular as people look for environmentally friendly options. Metal roofs can be recycled, decrease energy usage by reflecting heat, and collect rainwater that can be used for landscaping or other purposes.

These factors add more value to a property as they align with the increasing demand for sustainable living. Therefore, if you’re considering installing a metal roof, go for it – it won’t devalue your house, and it could even increase its resale value.

What Are the Disadvantages of a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs are becoming increasingly popular because they have several benefits, but they also have a few drawbacks. For one, metal roofs are quite expensive compared to asphalt-shingle roofs. They can cost anywhere between $8-12 per square foot installed, which is more than twice the price of asphalt shingles.

This can add up quickly, especially if you have a large roof.

Another disadvantage of metal roofs is that they can be noisy during heavy rain or hail storms. This can be a problem if you live in an area with frequent thunderstorms or hailstorms. The noise can be especially noticeable if you have an attic or sleeping area directly under the metal roof.

However, you can mitigate this by installing noise-reducing insulation during the installation process.

Does Metal Roof Decrease Value?

Metal roofs are often perceived as a costly investment because they can cost between $3 to $14 per square foot to install, which is a lot more than regular asphalt shingle roofs that cost only $1.75 per square foot. However, the expense of installing a metal roof shouldn’t be the only factor that homeowners should consider. Metal roofs offer several benefits, such as durability, low maintenance, long lifespan, and energy efficiency, which can make up for the initial cost in the long run.

Additionally, metal roofs can increase the home’s value and improve its aesthetic appeal. Therefore, metal roofs don’t decrease home value; instead, they add value to it.

In conclusion, a metal roof may be more expensive to install than a regular asphalt shingle roof, but it’s a worthwhile investment that can provide several benefits to homeowners.

Moreover, metal roofs don’t decrease home value; instead, they can enhance it in many ways.

Why Are Metal Roofs Not Popular?

Metal roofs are not popular in some areas due to their high initial cost. It’s true that metal roofs are more expensive than traditional asphalt shingles, which can turn some homeowners away from the prospect. Additionally, some people may have preconceived notions that metal roofs are noisy during rain and hailstorms, though this is not necessarily the case with modern metal roofing techniques.

Another factor that may make metal roofs less popular is their appearance.

Some homeowners prefer the look of traditional roofing materials like slate or clay tiles over metal. However, metal roofing technology has advanced in recent years, and there are now many different styles and colors available to suit different tastes. Ultimately, whether or not a metal roof is the right choice for a home will depend on a number of factors, including the homeowner’s budget, the local climate, and the desired aesthetics.

What Are the Disadvantages of Putting Metal Roof Over Shingles?

Putting metal roof over shingles may seem like a good idea at first, but it can actually have some major drawbacks. For starters, installing a metal roof over shingles means that your new roof won’t be able to ventilate properly. This can lead to moisture problems and mold growth in your attic or crawlspace.

Additionally, the extra weight of the metal roof can put a strain on your home’s existing structure, potentially leading to costly repairs down the line.

Furthermore, if you ever need to repair or replace your roof, having a metal roof over shingles can make the process much more difficult and expensive. In some cases, you may even need to remove the metal roof entirely before you can install a new roof. Overall, while putting a metal roof over shingles may seem like a quick and easy solution, it’s important to consider the long-term costs and potential problems before making a decision.


After researching and analyzing the debate over screw down metal roofs versus shingles, it is safe to say that the decision ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific circumstances. While metal roofs tend to have longer lifespans and durability against harsh weather conditions, they can be more expensive to install and may require more maintenance in the long run. Some homeowners may also find metal roofs to be louder during rainstorms and less visually appealing than traditional shingles.

However, it should be noted that with proper installation and maintenance, metal roofs are not more prone to leaking than shingles. Ultimately, the best choice for your roofing needs will depend on a variety of factors, including budget, climate, and aesthetic preferences.


Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *